Is Entrepreneurial Success Predictable? An Ex-Ante Analysis of the Character-Based Approach

AuthorsCaliendo, M. and Kritikos, A.S.
Year2008
ReferenceKyklos, 61(2), 189-214.
KeywordsEntrepreneurship, Psychological Assessment, Character-Based Approach, Success Prediction.
JEL-ClassificationM13, J23, C13
Presentations Annual Meeting Verein für Socialpolitik in Bayreuth (2006), 33rd EARIE conference in Amsterdam (2006), 2007 ESEM in Budapest.
DownloadIZA Discussion Paper from March 2007: PDF-DokumentPDF
Supplementary Appendix to the Published Version: PDF-DokumentPDF
AbstractThis paper empirically analyzes whether the character-based approach, which is based on the personality structure and the human capital of business founders, allows prediction of entrepreneurial success. A unique data set is used consisting of 414 previously unemployed persons whose personal characteristics were screened by different methods, namely a one-day assessment center (AC) and a standardized questionnaire, before they launched their business. Results are partly unexpected: first, there is almost no correlation between the AC data and the questionnaire. Second, the predictive power of the AC data is slightly better than that of the questionnaire, but lower than expected in theory. Interestingly, for those subgroups where the AC data have low predictive power, the questionnaire does better. Third, when success is measured in terms of employees hired, the character-based approach is a poor predictor.